Is All Error Consequential?

By Bob Myhan

This writer does not believe all error is consequential. One cannot afford to be wrong about some things but can afford to be wrong about other things.

One can put all actions in three categories: (1) actions God demands, (2) actions God permits and (3) actions God forbids.

One must do what God demands; may do what God permits; and must not do what God forbids. If one does not do what God demands or if he does what God forbids—and never repents—he will suffer the consequence of eternal punishment.

Thus, one cannot afford to treat actions in the first category as if they were in the second or third category; and one cannot afford to treat actions in the third category as if they were in the first or second category. To treat things in the second category, however, as if they were in the first or third category is ultimately inconsequential, so long as one judges only oneself in those things. One does not have to do everything God permits. Therefore, it is inconsequential if one is wrong in thinking God forbids an action that He actually permits

The eating of meat, for example, is in the category of things God permits. But if one cannot eat meat with confidence, he should not eat it. His own conscience puts it into the category of actions God forbids (Rom. 14:23). This does not mean, however, that he may condemn one who can eat meat with confidence. To do so is to act uncharitably and sin against his brother, which God forbids ( Rom. 14:1-13).

Examples of Consequential Error

In Romans, Paul gives a list of actions that are “worthy of death” (1:18-32). That this is not an exhaustive list is evident from the fact that he gives two similar lists in 1 Corinthians (5:9-11; 6:9,10) and a third list in Galatians (5:16-21). Each of these lists includes things not included in the others.

When one teaches that actions worthy of death are not worthy of death [or that “the works of the flesh” will not keep one from entering the kingdom of God] he is treating actions that God forbids as though they were actions God permits— precisely what the serpent did in the Garden of Eden (Gen. 3:1-6). He encourages those he teaches to do what God has forbidden. Since the actions themselves are consequential, encouraging one to so act is also consequential.

Then He said to the disciples, "It is impossible that no offenses should come, but woe to him through whom they do come! It would be better for him if a millstone were hung around his neck, and he were thrown into the sea, than that he should offend one of these little ones.” (Luke 17:1-2)

“Whoever therefore breaks one of the least of these commandments, and teaches men so, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven; but whoever does and teaches them, he shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.” (Luke 17:1-2)

God insists that alien sinners believe that Jesus is the Son of God, repent of sins, confess faith and be baptized for the remission of sins (see Mark 16:16; Acts 2:38; Rom. 10:9-10). If someone teaches that God does not demand one or more of these actions, he is hindering them from receiving the remission of their sins. Thus, it is consequential to convince others of this error or to be convinced of this error by others.

Jesus said, “God is Spirit, and those who worship Him must worship in spirit and truth” (John 4:24). It is therefore necessary to know how to worship “in spirit and truth.” Both those who do not worship “in spirit” and those who do not worship “in truth” are guilty of consequential error.

Since God forbids us to do anything “in word or deed” without authority from Jesus (Col. 3:17), to teach or practice anything without His authority is consequential. To use instrumental music in worship without the Lord’s authority is consequential. And to extend congregational benevolence to non-saints without the Lord’s authority is consequential.

It is one thing to be wrong in what you believe to be the truth, such as believing that an action is demanded when it is not or believing an action is forbidden when it is not, but it is quite another thing to teach or practice something that Jesus has not authorized. That is, one may be incorrect in his thinking but correct in his practice.

Since God forbids divorce [except when one’s spouse is guilty of fornication] and remarriage after divorce [except for one who has divorced his/her spouse for fornication], to teach otherwise is to encourage adultery (Matt. 19:9). This, also, is consequential error. One may believe certain errors with impunity, but he may not teach and/or practice error with impunity.

If God demands that every woman throughout the church age wear an artificial covering on her head during worship, those women who do not do so are guilty of a sin of omission. If, on the other hand, God does not demand that every woman throughout the church age wear an artificial covering on her head during worship, those who teach that He does demand it are guilty of teaching error. But this error is consequential only for the teacher. Those women who are convinced that God demands such are not wrong in covering their heads, unless God forbids them to cover their heads. Rather, they would be wrong if they did not cover their heads. And one should not ridicule anyone for doing what they believe they must do.

Those who wish to restrict their teaching and practice to that which has been authorized by Jesus Christ will not teach or practice anything for which they have not found a “thus saith the Lord.” No one who truly believes in hell wants to be wrong in his teaching or practice. But those who really want to go to heaven will always be ready to re-examine their teaching and practice in the light of God’s word.

When an honestly mistaken person understands the truth, he can no longer be honestly mistaken. He will either cease to be mistaken or cease to be honest. &

Do Not Be Lifted Up With Pride!

By R.J. Evans

Pride is a sin that is condemned many times in the Bible, yet it is so deceptive and insidious that it threatens all of us in various ways. It is such a dangerous sin, because it is so easily seen and loathed in others, but rarely recognized in one’s own life.

The sin of pride has kept multitudes of individuals from obeying God and faithfully doing His will. The first thing required of any person who would please God is to humble himself. And pride keeps so many from ever doing what God has commanded in such passages as James 4:10: “Humble yourselves in the sight of the Lord, And He will lift you up.”

God’s attitude toward pride is expressed in such passages as Proverbs 16:5:

Everyone who is proud in heart is an abomination to the Lord.

One of the seven abominations that God hates is “A proud look.” (Proverbs 6:17)

Even when we have done some good deed, we must be careful not to allow pride to step in and cause us to “blow our own horn” — “do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing” (Matt. 6:3). The Bible says, “Let another man praise you, and not your own mouth; A stranger, and not your own lips” (Prov. 27:2). In other words, if there is a reason we should be praised, let it be done by our friends, brethren or companions with modesty. We may have done something worthwhile, but let us not forget that the value of the deed may be grossly inflated in our own minds. But, in the minds of our listeners, the deed, no matter how good, may hardly be accepted for the value we perceive it to have. So when we do our good works and good deeds, don’t exaggerate, overstate or magnify them—they may become the biggest enemy we have—don’t nourish them by boasting! If they are truly worthwhile, the world will know about it. Then we can graciously receive commendation, and retain the utmost respect in doing so.

Someone has said that pride is “the welcome mat to every spiritual prison cell.” Pride can be such a stronghold — it cheats wherever it plays. We close with the following thoughts taken from the book, PRAYING GOD’S WORD, pages 59-60:

My name is Pride. I am a cheater.

I cheat you of your God-given destiny because you demand your own way.

I cheat you of contentment because you deserve better than this.

I cheat you of knowledge because you already know it all.

I cheat you of healing because you’re too full of me to forgive.

I cheat you of holiness because you refuse to admit when you’re wrong.

I cheat you of vision because you’d rather look in the mirror than out a window.

I cheat you of genuine friendship because nobody’s going to know the real you.

I cheat you of love because true love demands sacrifice.

I cheat you of greatness because you refuse to “wash another’s feet.”

I cheat you of God’s glory because I convince you to seek your own.

My name is Pride. I am a cheater.

You like me because you think I’m always looking out for you. Untrue.

I’m looking to make a fool of you.

God has so much for you, I admit, but don’t worry. If you stick with me you’ll never know. &